Reversing a Tour route

Can you reverse a route on a tour and still get all of the stops? For instance, in Rome we are staying at Piazza Navona and want to do the tour “Spanish Steps to Piazza Navona” but in reverse to start from near our hotel.

Does the app reroute to our starting point? If not would be a great feature!

Hi @diane.soule Thanks for your question.

Most VoiceMap follow a set route, starting from a specific point, and this is how we can match audio times to travel times and include turn-by-turn directions

So, in answer to your question no, you can’t reverse a route on a tour – at least not in the case of the vast majority of tours, and when this is possible, it is clearly stated in the tour description.

VoiceMap’s tours almost all include turn-by-turn directions, and if you started a tour at the end and did it in reverse, left turns would become right turns.

Beyond that, the tours are all carefully timed so that audio duration matches travel duration. This means that the audio that starts automatically at point X is under two minutes if the walk to point Y is two minutes, but the same is not true in reverse. The audio for Y might be 3 minutes because the walk to point Z takes that long, and so if you go in reverse it would still be playing by the time you arrived at point X.

But finally, and most importantly, because we’ve built the experience around giving directions and timing the audio, the playback is also sequenced for better accuracy, so automatic playback won’t actually work at all in reverse.

The response and explanation makes sense! Even still, so many times we want to do it in reverse…

I had an idea of using the map and not step by step narration, but often the narration points out things along the way as we’re walking so that wouldn’t work. UNLESS… tour guides had the choice of making their tour reversible, and they created it with that in mind. F so…

When using the reverse option. Users did not put away their phone with map. HONESTLY, I ALWAYS keep my phone map open bc there have been too many “not all who wander are lost” messages after we’ve gotten far enough off track due to either poor instructions, poor gps reception, or we’ve become distracted.

From now on, users could have the choice of narrated turn by turn instructions (perhaps only on “forward”), or map assisted self guided route.

  1. All turn by turn instructions would be separated from the guides touring narration. Example stop 1 would have narration and then it pings hen done. And the to next stop going would start. The narration while walking could continue, but every time there was a specific site we’d be passing or there was a turn instruction, it would ping and that narration would stop and the route instructions would play. There would be a “ping” when done.
  2. If “to next stop” were only available for forward, the instructions could play immediately (if user didn’t turn on “map assisted walking”). There would be a “to next stop button” one could press and that section of map would magnify making it easier to and follow, or it might switch to a Google/AppleMap type mapping “set on walk” (where it pings when we must pay attention to the turn). If using a separate mapping, on arrived, we’d need to return to VM. (Could it pop up onto a split screen where VM’s screen at this point only had a “continue VM” button so the Google map would close? I would LOVE this even on forward so I’m not relying on the narrator to get me to next stop!!!

Where there’s a will, there’s a way- even if at a minimum, the forward turn instructions were separated from the narration and those either not play on reverse or it were easy to “skip” it, and reverse users accepted the to next stop instructions were not available and we were OnourOwn to get to the next numbered/named location on the map.

(As for timing to the next stop, in reverse, could there be a “check point” a half block or whatever before the next stop and if narration isn’t finished, a phantom stop would appear

Hi,

Thanks for such a thoughtful and detailed post. It’s clear you’ve given this a lot of thought, and a lot of what you describe comes from real experience of walking tours and getting a bit lost along the way.

You’re right that narration often points out things as you walk, and that’s part of what makes reversing a tour so hard. Each tour is built as a sequence, with the audio, the turn-by-turn directions and the timing all designed for one direction of travel. Playing it backwards would mean changing every audio file, not just flipping the directions. The narration would need to be re-recorded or restructured so that what you hear matches what you’re passing, and so that each clip fits the walk to the next stop. In practice, a reverse version would essentially be a separate tour.

We see that as a trade-off rather than a flaw. VoiceMap tours are narrated by people who actually live in and love the places they’re talking about, and that local voice is the heart of the experience. A tour written and recorded for one walking route is what makes it feel like a local is walking beside you, but it does mean the route isn’t easily reversible.

These are interesting ideas, and we’ll pass them on to the team as feedback. Thanks again for taking the time to write it all out.

1 Like

Back at you. I guess o should have said.. like GPSMy City, but instead of reading the narrative, the voice is recorded. (A live tour guide often does not talk along the way bc people can’t hear.) don’t get me wrong: I LOVE VM the way it is. But having the choice to sometimes give up the talknwalk for reverse touring would be great when it’s ia one way tour and it might be fun to explore the end point area instead of walking quickly all the way to the start to begin the tour to the way back.

Having the option to put away your phone OR walking with a more user-friendly map option such as touching next location and getting an enlarged tout map to next location which pinged and voice begins when you arrive) to use when gps isn’t “exact-location reliable” (as in narrow-street old cities AND. In skyscraper lined Modern cities) would be great anyway Using it in reverse would be just a bonus:)

On a similar vein. I understand the difficultes associated with reversing a tour but most of these would not apply to starting a tour at an intermediate point. Is the inability to do this technical or policy? I think it would be a useful addition.

Hi Ian,

Good news, this is closer to existing than you might think. VoiceMap has a Resume Tour button, and it can be used to start a tour partway through. Open the tour from your Library, tap Resume Tour, and the app shows the three closest locations to where you are, so you can join from a stop near you. There’s a walkthrough here: Can I stop and resume my tour? | VoiceMap Help Center

It’s mainly designed for picking up where you left off after a break, so starting this way works a bit differently from a normal start. Tours are built as a sequence, with each audio clip and direction following on from the one before, and the experience is designed around beginning at the first stop. If you join midway you’ll miss the earlier locations, and the audio and directions may not feel quite as polished as they would on a full run.

So to answer your question, it isn’t a policy against starting at an intermediate point. The tours are built to be walked in order, and Resume is the way to get around that when you need to.

Good news. I love both how great the app is and how responsive you guys are! So as Long as I’m asking, is there a way to allow us to make comments to ourselves? This would. be so handy if we want to revisit it on another trip (and maybe continue where we left off), make personal recommendations to friends, and also so we could make some notes in case we aren’t able to review it then and there. (I’ve just come across a bunch I didn’t review in the past and unfortunately may only and hopefully still remember I thought it was great, good, or not so good. I am finding I can’t make many specific comments which I depend upon from other travelers when deciding which tours to do.

Hi @home happy to hear that! We have some great updates to listener profiles coming soon. It won’t include a notes option just yet, but this is a great suggestion, and we’ll share it with the team. Iain included a sneak preview of the updated listener profiles on his response to your question on tour reviews here: Requests from a User: Reviewing and App saving - #2 by iain